
Robin is Director in charge of the Leeds office, bringing experience in project management and monitoring, contract administration, technical due diligence, building pathology and party wall surveying. He also has a keen interest in developing sustainability opportunities across his projects and services.
He has recent experience acting as programme director for high rise cladding remediation works for a leading national student accommodation provider and having completed the RICS EWS1 Assessor course, has enhanced understanding and competence in cladding consultancy. He has led and developed building and project consultancy teams nationally while working in the Leeds marketplace for over 20 years.
Robin’s experience includes new build, refurbishment and fit-out projects as well as managing survey programmes regionally and nationally. His work covers commercial property sectors including industrial, retail, residential, education and healthcare, for clients such as British Land, Patrizia, Land Securities, Quadrant Estates, Walgreens-Boots Alliance, CO-OP, Aberdeen and the Department for Transport.


A PAS 9980 assessment can help building owners understand external wall fire risk and make informed decisions about remediation. But as we explore in our articles explaining PAS 9980 and comparing the new changes in PAS 9980:20206, this technical risk assessment shouldn’t be considered as a statement of compliance, or a shield against future liability.
While the guidance evolves, so does the picture of risk facing building owners. It is no longer enough to ask, "What is the risk rating?" of an asset. Increasingly, owners need to ask:
"What assumptions have we made, how resilient is this asset, and how will our decisions be viewed when the building is refinanced, transferred or sold?”
A PAS 9980 assessment examines a specific issue: the risk of fire spread via external walls. It provides a valuable snapshot of risk at a particular moment, based on the information available at the time.
However, recent legal decisions, evolving regulation and changing market expectations demonstrate a widening scope for building safety risk.
Liability may arise from historic defects, contractual obligations, remediation responsibilities or wider building safety concerns, regardless of whether a PAS 9980 assessment concludes that external wall risk is tolerable. Equally, lenders, insurers, purchasers and regulators are increasingly looking beyond certificates and reports to understand how decisions were reached and whether risks have been properly investigated and managed.
The industry's focus is gradually shifting from proving compliance towards demonstrating competence and good judgement.
That reflects a broader trend we describe as the emergence of a "web of knowledge" across the built environment: a dynamic in which owners, consultants, contractors and specialists share more information and challenge each others’ assumptions to build a more complete understanding of how a building performs, and where its risks lay.
This is integral to improving building safety decisions now, knowing that they may well be revisited in years to come.
A future purchaser may want to understand why a remediation strategy was chosen. A regulator may examine whether reasonable investigations were undertaken. An insurer may ask what evidence supported a decision not to intervene. In each case, the strength of the decision will often depend on the quality of the evidence behind it.
Recent transactions have also demonstrated the growing importance of building safety due diligence. Purchasers, lenders and their advisers may seek comfort not only on the conclusions of a FRAEW, but also on the investigations, assumptions, supporting evidence and professional reliance arrangements sitting behind it. A building's future liquidity may therefore depend not just on the PAS 9980 outcome itself, but on the strength, durability and transferability of the evidence underpinning that outcome. A tolerable outcome may therefore be only one factor in determining how readily an asset can be refinanced, transferred or sold in the future.
For building owners, this means creating and maintaining a comprehensive audit trail, including:
• Construction and design information
• Intrusive investigation findings
• Remediation options considered
• Records of key decisions and approvals
• Residual risks and management measures
• Ongoing reviews and monitoring arrangements
We believe that the ability to explain why a decision was taken will prove to be commercially and reputationally critical.
Owners should view PAS 9980 as one component of a wider asset resilience strategy, rather than the endpoint of the process. While a PAS 9980 outcome may indicate that remediation is not currently recommended, many owners will also need to consider longer-term objectives such as insurability, refinancing, investor expectations, resident confidence and the future disposal of the asset.
This raises an important question: should a building be judged solely on whether remediation is required today, or on how resilient, marketable and attractive the asset is likely to remain in five, ten or fifteen years' time?
For many owners, the challenge is one of stewardship and governance, balancing today's risk assessment against tomorrow's commercial, funding and asset management objectives.
A tolerable PAS 9980 outcome may be sufficient from a fire risk perspective today, but it is not the end of the story. Owners should also consider whether proportionate improvements would strengthen an asset’s long-term resilience, improve insurability and future financing or sale.
In some cases, targeted improvements delivered through planned maintenance programmes may enhance resilience while reducing disruption and cost. These might include upgrading cavity barriers when undertaking façade maintenance, addressing combustible balcony elements, or incorporating fire safety improvements alongside window replacement projects.
Delivering these measures as part of wider asset investment programmes can often be more efficient than returning to undertake standalone works at a later date, though could be constrained by funding as they won’t be grant-funded.
PAS 9980 can help owners understand a specific fire risk. The next challenge is deciding what that outcome means for the long-term future and liquidity of the asset. The appropriate response will vary by assets, but a crucial first step is to use a tolerable PAS 9980 outcome as a stepping stone for future action to improve your assets’ long-term outlook.
In an environment where expectations continue to evolve, the strongest position is not simply demonstrating compliance. It is having a clear strategy for managing both building safety risk and long-term asset resilience, value and liquidity.
This article forms part of TFT’s In Safe Hands insight and advice series, for building owners seeking to create safer buildings sooner.
TFT can help you make sense of the regulatory requirements and the wider picture of risk which arises from building safety issues. Our team can help you understand your goals and determine the right action and evidence to achieve them.
We bring together the fire, façade, structural, project and commercial expertise needed to create demonstrably safer buildings.